Show Menu

Wetenschapsfilosofie Engels W5 Cheat Sheet by

Wetenschapsfilosofie Engels

Struct­uralism to Genera­tivism

• Genera­tivism as succeeded by struct­uralism (de Saussure);
• Struct­uralism w/ emphasis on segmen­tation and classi­fic­ation; catalo­guing elements, their relations and distri­but­ions;
• Struct­ura­lism's main contri­bution: method­olo­gical (according to Chomsky); the idea of language as a formal system;
• Struct­uralism makes it possible to address the problems posed by UG (SR p5).

Noam Chomsky (1928-)

• creator of the theory of gene­rative grammar, one of the most signif­icant contri­butions to the field of lingui­stics in the 20th century;
• genuine insights in lingui­stics imply an unders­tanding of aspects of mental processing and human nature

Mental­istic Approach of Genera­tivism

Genera­tivism forms a return to Kant:
simi­lar­iti­es: emphasis on mental structures which experience (learning a language) can order (‘setting the parame­ters’), but which cannot be derived from experience (they are geneti­cally determ­ined);
diff­ere­nce: for Chomsky, these structures are not just transc­end­ental, found only through philos­ophical reflec­tion, but can form the object of empirical (cognitive psycho­log­ical) research.

A Universal Grammar (UG)

➝ the ability to learn grammar is hard-wired
➝ provides insight into the use and acquis­ition of language
➝ not just descri­ptive but also explan­atory
➝ distin­ction between deep structure and surface structure

Chomsky advocates a return to the idea of a universal grammar; the kind of grammar that flourished in the 17th and 18th centuries;
“con­cerned with general features of language structure rather than with particular idiosy­ncr­aci­es”

The decline of universal grammar

Tradition of universal grammar came to an end in the 19th century:
➝ dismissed as too metaph­ysi­cal;
too ambiti­ous: “the problems posed were beyond the scope of the technique and unders­tanding then available”
the problem of rule-g­overned creati­vity: how is it that from an early age onwards, children can create sentences they have never heard?
➝ ousted by IE compar­ative lingui­stics

Generative grammar

Object of resear­ch: syntax only (auton­omous component) (SR p21);
Only this part of the grammar is suscep­tible to rules: “The fundam­ental aim in the linguistic analysis of a language L is to separate the gram­mat­ical sequences which are sentences of L from the ungr­amm­ati­cal sequences which are not sentences of L and to study the gramma­tical sequences. The grammar of L will thus be a device that generates all of the gramma­tical sequences of L and none of the ungram­matical ones.” (SR p18)


Gramma­tic­alness cannot be determined by:
- a corpus of utterances (perfo­rmance)
- meaning (seman­tics):
- frequency of use

the rules of grammar as formulated in the language of mathem­atics and logic;
econ­omy: by specifying a finite number of rules the grammar can generate an infinite number of sentences (rec­urs­ivi­ty);
accounts for creativity in language
S ➝ NP + VP
VP ➝ V + NP
NP ➝ D + N
D ➝ the
N ➝ boy, dog
V ➝ chased
The boy chased the dog
The dog chased the boy

Chomsky's Evaluation

• Linguistic theory must provide the means to evaluate possible grammars
Possible gramma­rs: devices that generate the gramma­tical sentences of a language
• Such a grammar must be desc­rip­tively adequate in the sense that it is able to disamb­iguate ambiguous sentences, i.e., sentences with an identical surface structure (signal, form), but with different semantic interp­ret­ations (deep struct­ures)

Competence vs Perfor­mance vs Saussure

Perf­orm­ance: what speakers do (= de Saussure’s parole);
Comp­ete­nce: an individual native speaker’s implicit knowledge of the language (≠ de Saussure’s langue)

➝ Both de Saussure and Chomsky regard language as a system and ignore individual speech acts;
➝ Chomsky’s competence is a psycho­logical phenom­enon, imprinted in the mind, not a shared generality but a genetic endowment in each indivi­dual; its basis is universal grammar;
➝ de Saussure’s langue is a socio-­psy­cho­logical phenomenon shared among a community of speakers and is language specific.

• "The only legitimate object of linguistic research is the competence of the ideal native speake­r" (Chomsky)

Innateness vs UG

• “a universal grammar – a general theory of linguistic structure that determines the form of grammar – is primarily of interest for the inform­ation it provides concerning innate intell­ectual structure”
• language acquis­ition and use are made possible by a particular component in the human mind: the language faculty, consisting of a Universal Grammar;
• languages scarcely differ at the level of deep structure – which reflects the basic properties of thought and conception – but that they may vary widely at the much less intere­sting level of surface structure
➝ the rapid language acquis­ition of children
➝ the poverty of the stimulus;
➝ creative language use of native speakers;
➝ competent critical period (sensitive period)
➝ gave rise to the nature vs nurture debate

Genera­tivism: a new paradigm (Kuhn)

field: syntax as an autonomous component
emph­asis: eval­uat­ion instead of discovery
tool: gramma­tic­ality judgments (i.e., informal elicit­ation) of data

Prin­ciples & Parame­ters:
Prin­cip­les: abstract rules of grammar, common to all languages
Para­met­ers: markers or switches that are turned on or off for particular languages and determine variab­ility
Gove­rnment & Binding Theory:
Gove­rnm­ent: an abstract syntactic relation mainly concerned w/ the assignment of case > all languages have abstract case though they may not have morpho­logical case
Bind­ing: an abstract syntactic relation mainly concerned with the referents of pronouns, anaphors (refle­xives) and refere­ntial expres­sions

Help Us Go Positive!

We offset our carbon usage with Ecologi. Click the link below to help us!

We offset our carbon footprint via Ecologi


No comments yet. Add yours below!

Add a Comment

Your Comment

Please enter your name.

    Please enter your email address

      Please enter your Comment.

          Related Cheat Sheets

          More Cheat Sheets by Soraya

          Wetenschapsfilosofie Engels W3 Cheat Sheet