Cheatography
https://cheatography.com
と言う different meanings と言う different meanings と言う different meanings
This is a draft cheat sheet. It is a work in progress and is not finished yet.
と言う
~と言うか(というか)“or rather / I mean / how should I put it…” |
** |
** |
** |
** |
The speaker says something, then adjusts, softens, or searches for a more accurate way to express it. |
|
|
|
|
Aというか、B |
= A… or rather, B. |
Nuance: that A isn't necessarily completely wrong. The speaker feels that A doesn't express the idea perfectly, so they add B. |
🧠 Memory image A → 🤔 → B “I said A… hmm… actually, B is closer.” |
| |
彼は優しいというか、ちょっとおせっかいなんだ。 |
He's kind… or rather, he's a little meddlesome. |
疲れたというか、もう何もしたくない。 |
I'm tired… or rather, I don't want to do anything anymore. |
Here, 疲れた is the first approximation. The speaker then explains the stronger/more precise feeling. |
A useful way to think about them is:
と言うか → “or rather…” → I want to correct/rephrase what I just said
と言うと → “speaking of / when you say…” → I’m reacting to a word/idea just mentioned
と言うより → “rather than…” → A is not quite right; B is more accurate
と言っても → “although I say…” → what I just said sounds stronger/different than the reality
|
~というと vs ~というか
~と言うか(というか)“or rather / I mean / how should I put it…” |
~と言うと(というと)“when you say A…” / “speaking of A…” / “if you mention A…” |
~というと vs ~というか |
The speaker says something, then adjusts, softens, or searches for a more accurate way to express it. |
It takes something that has just been mentioned or brought to mind and uses it as a starting point for the next statement. |
|
Pattern: |
Pattern: |
Compare: |
Aというか、B |
Aというと、B |
東京というと、何を思い浮かべますか。 |
= A… or rather, B. |
=Speaking of A, B. |
Speaking of Tokyo / When you hear Tokyo, what comes to mind? |
The important nuance is that A isn't necessarily completely wrong. The speaker feels that A doesn't express the idea perfectly, so they add B. |
Aというと、どういう意味ですか。 When you say A, what do you mean? |
= You're taking Tokyo as a topic/trigger. |
例: |
例: |
But: |
彼は優しいというか、ちょっとおせっかいなんだ。He's kind… or rather, he's a little meddlesome. |
日本の夏というと、暑さを思い出します。 When I think of Japanese summer, I think of the heat. |
東京というか、日本の大都市は人が多い。 Tokyo—or rather, big Japanese cities—are crowded. |
=Here, 疲れた is the first approximation. The speaker then explains the stronger/more precise feeling. |
=The phrase 日本の夏 triggers the association. |
= You're correcting/rephrasing your previous expression. |
| |
東京というと、何を思い浮かべますか。 When you hear “Tokyo,” what comes to mind? |
Easy distinction |
🧠 Memory image: A → 🤔 → B |
Important nuance: というと often has an association/trigger feeling: |
というと = A makes me think of B |
“I said A… hmm… actually, B is closer.” |
A → 💭 B : A makes you think of B. |
というか = A… actually, B |
|
というか vs というより vs といっても
~と言うより(というより)“rather than A, B” |
** |
** |
This is used when A is not the best description, and B is closer to the truth. |
|
|
Pattern |
Aというより、B |
Rather than A, it's B. |
より — the comparison particle: more than / rather than / compared with |
例: |
「優しい」と言うより、「甘い」と言ったほうが近い。Rather than calling him “kind,” it's more appropriate to call him “lenient.” |
|
|
|
|
|