Cheatography
https://cheatography.com
AQA sociology paper 2 option : beliefs in society
This is a draft cheat sheet. It is a work in progress and is not finished yet.
Durkheim on religion
- Society is a system of interrelated parts |
- Society has needs which are met by different institutions |
I.E - religion, media |
|
The sacred and the profane |
Sacred: |
Things that are set apart, are surrounded by prohibitions and taboos and create feelings of awe |
Profane: |
Things that are mundane and ordinary |
That powerful feelings evoked by the sacred implies that it represents something of great power - Society |
|
Totenism: |
The essence of religion could be discovered by studying it in its somplest form in its simplest society |
Collective conscience: |
Sacred symbols represent society's collective conscience |
Cognitive functions of religion: |
- Religion is the source of our ability to reason and think conceptually |
- Religion is the origin of shared categories |
I.E. space, time |
- The splitting of clans gave the first ideas of classification |
|
**Criticisms of Durkheim |
Worsley: |
There isn't a clear division between the sacred and profance |
- The splitting of clans gave the first ideas of classification |
Postmodernists: |
increasing diversity as fractured the collective conscience |
Psychological functions: MALINOWSKI
- Helps individuals cope with stress that could undermine solidarity |
|
Study: Tribriant Islanders |
Where the outcome is uncertain: |
- Fishing in the Lagoon: |
no rituals as outcome is certain and safe |
- Fishing in the Ocean: |
had rituals as outcome is uncertain and dangerous |
|
At time of life crises: |
- Events such as birth and death can cause disruptive changes in social groups |
- Religion brings poeple together and explains why these happen |
Parsons: Value and Meaning
Religion helps people cope with uncertainty |
Creates and legitimates society’s values: Religion sacralises values thus promoting solidarity |
Provides a source of meaning: Religion answers unanswerable questions, helping people to adjust |
Civil Religion: Bellah
A belief system that attaches sacred qualities to society |
Integrates society in a way that individual religion can’t |
Involves loyalty to the nation state and a belief in God = being a true American |
|
Functional alternatives |
Non-religious beliefs and practices that perform the same functions as religion |
Ignores what makes religion distinct |
Marxist view on religion
Society is split into 2 classes: Bourgeoisie and Proletariat |
Religion is a feature of a divided society and wouldn’t be needed in a communist society |
For Marx if we lived in a communist society there would be no need for religion. |
Religion dulls the pain of oppression |
It leads the proletariat into a false state of consciousness. |
|
Religion and Social Control |
- Religion distorts reality |
- Encourages the belief that supernatural beings control events and there is nothing humans can do about itb |
- Religion legitimises the inequality which exists in society |
-Engels: In the 1800s British Bourgeoisie spent large sums of money |
- To support mainstream Christian organisations |
Religion as compensaton
- religion compensates for the misery of those who have been exploited |
- I.E. Christianity offers the reward of heavenly escape |
- religion promises happiness although the happiness it promises is just an illusion |
- true happiness can only be obtained by the exploited shaking off the oppression and practising their freedom |
Religion as ideology
- religion distorts perceptions of reality to benefit the ruling class |
- class that controls the economic base also controls production and distribution of ideas |
- religion used as a weapon to justify inequality/suffering |
- creates a false consciousness |
Lenin: |
Religion is a spiritual GIn, creating a mystical fog |
makes the ruling class's position appear divinely ordained |
Religion as alienation
religion is a productin of alienation |
workers are alienated because they have no freedom to express teir true natureh |
Marx: |
' religion is the opium of the people, fulling their pain |
Feminist Theory of Religion
Evidence of Patriarchy |
- Religious organisations: |
Mainly male dominated |
|
*BUT... |
|
Higher rates of female participation |
- Places of worship: |
Often segregate the sexes |
|
Women's participation may be restricted |
- Sacred texts |
Largely feature male gods |
|
Female sterotypes |
|
Interpreted/written by men |
- Religious laws and customs: |
Woman may have fewer rights |
|
Religious influence on culture may lead to unequal treatment |
|
Woodhead: religious forms of feminism |
- patriarchy may not be true for all religion |
- argues the Hijab is liberating for women |
- pentecostal groups are empowering for women |
Religion and social change
Sociologists have studied the role of religion in society and observed 2 broad camps |
1. Those who see religion as a conservative force |
religion - force for stability and order |
2. Those who see religion as a force for social change |
supporters of this position point to the role of religion in encouraging societies to change |
|
Perspectives view on Religion's functions |
Functionalists |
religion maintains social stablility |
Marxism |
religion prevents social change by justifying exploitation |
Feminists |
religion is an ideology that legitimises partiarchy |
|
WEBER: Religion as a force for change |
Protestant ethic and the spirit of capitalism |
Calvinist beliefs were the beginning of modern capitalism |
|
Calvinist beliefs |
Pre destination: |
God had decided who the elect would be and nothing could change that fate |
Divine transcendence: |
No one could claim to know the will of God |
|
- caused Calvinists to feel inner loneliness which combined with pre-destination caused a salvation panic |
This wordly ascension: |
Abstaining from luxury |
|
- denial whilst still being part of society |
Calling: |
Any wealth made was put back into the businesses |
|
- combined with concept of asceticism |
|
Hinduism |
- ascetic |
- other worldly |
followers focus on spiritual world |
|
Confucianism |
- this worldly |
not ascetic |
Evaluation
Marxism: Overestimates the role of ideas and underestimates
economic factors
Tawney: Technological changes caused capitalism
Capitalism didn’t occur in every country where there was Calvinism
American civil rights movement: BRUCE
Churches provided sanctuary and support |
Rituals and prayer united members |
Ideological resource: Provided beliefs and practices that protestors could use as support |
Taking the moral high ground: Pointed out the hypocrisy of the white clergy preaching ‘Love thy neighbour’ |
Channelling dissent: Religion provides channels for expressing political dissent |
Acting as the honest broker: Provide a context for negotiation as churches are often respected by both sides |
Mobilising public opinion: Campaign for support across the whole country |
The new Christian right: Bruce
- protestant fundamentalist |
- seeks to take USA back to God |
divorce, homoseuxality and abortion illegal |
- believes in the nuclear family |
|
*Why has it been unsuccessful? |
- moral majority = 15% |
- found it hard to work with other issues over the same issues |
- strong opposition |
- comparison to American civil rights |
NEO MARXIST: Religion as a force for change
Relative autonomy - independence from the economic base |
Religion can have dual character prompting change as well as stability |
MARX: 'The soul |
'the soul of the souless' |
|
'the heart of the heartless world' |
ENGELS: |
religion inhibits change by disguising inequality but it can also challenge the status quo |
|
BLOCH: the principle of hope |
- religion may inspire protest and revolution |
- religion is an expression of the principle of hope which shows images of utopia |
- utopian images show what needs changing |
|
Libreration theology |
Emerged in the Latin American Catholic church |
Commitment to the poor and opposition to dictators |
Due to increased poverty and human rights abuses |
Praxis: |
practical action guided by theory |
Condemned by Pope John Paull II for being too Marxist |
Church continues to defend democracy |
Maduro: |
an exmaple of religiously inspired social change |
The pentecostal challenge
Lehmann explains why pentecostalism is now more popular among the poor in Latin America |
|
|
|
|
|