State Crime Theory
Core Idea: |
States can commit crimes when they violate domestic or international law, or fundamental human rights, through action or omission |
Key Figures: |
Stanley Cohen – states of denial. |
|
Penny Green & Tony Ward – state crime and human rights. |
MKULTRA Relevance: |
Conducted illegal human experimentation, often without consent, violating the Nuremberg Code (1947). |
|
Activities were concealed through classification, false reporting, and destruction of records. |
|
Illustrates state-corporate crime — CIA partnered with universities, hospitals, and pharmaceutical companies. |
Analytical Point: |
Shows how states can justify illegal acts under the guise of national security. |
Differential Association Theory
Core Idea: |
Criminal behaviour is learned through interaction with others |
Key Figure: |
Edwin H Sutherland |
MKULTRA Relevance: |
Operatives, scientists, and doctors working on MKULTRA learned techniques of deception, coercion, and non-consensual experimentation from one another. |
|
Created a subculture where ethical norms were inverted — illegal actions were normalised as patriotic duty. |
Analytical Point: |
Professional networks and covert culture reinforced deviant methods. |
Neutralisation Theory
Core Idea: |
Offenders use justifications to neutralise guilt and maintain a positive self-image. |
Key Figures: |
Gresham Sykes & David Matza |
MKULTRA Relevance: |
Denial of Injury: “The greater good of national security outweighs harm to individuals.” |
|
Appeal to Higher Loyalties: “Protecting America from communism justifies extreme measures.” |
|
Denial of Victim: Subjects seen as expendable or as enemy sympathisers. |
Analytical Point: |
These rationalisations helped participants continue unethical work without moral breakdown. |
|
|
Strain Theory
Core Idea: |
Crime can result from the pressure to achieve societal goals when legitimate means are blocked. |
Key Figure: |
Robert K. Merton |
MKULTRA Relevance: |
Cold War paranoia created pressure to achieve perfect interrogation/mind control techniques before the Soviets. |
|
CIA saw “normal” scientific progress as too slow — resorted to illicit, high-risk experimentation. |
Analytical Point: |
Shows how Cold War competition functioned as a structural strain encouraging deviance. |
Techniques of State Secrecy
Core Idea: |
Powerful actors use secrecy, bureaucracy, and manipulation of law to conceal wrongdoing |
Key Figures: |
Jock Young – criminology of the powerful |
|
Laureen Snider – corporate/state crime cover-ups |
MKULTRA Relevance: |
Use of front organisations, code names, and fragmented funding streams to hide activities. |
|
Destruction of records in 1973 to prevent exposure during Watergate climate. |
|
Manipulating research grants to universities to mask the true purpose. |
Analytical Point: |
Demonstrates how state power enables crimes that ordinary citizens cannot commit or hide. |
Victimology
Core Idea: |
The study of victims and victimisation patterns |
MKULTRA Relevance: |
Many subjects came from vulnerable groups: psychiatric patients, prisoners, sex workers, addicts, homeless individuals. |
|
The CIA targeted those with low social capital to minimise backlash. |
|
Victims were often unaware they had been experimented on until decades later. |
Analytical Point: |
MKULTRA shows structural victimisation — harm inflicted on those least able to resist or seek justice. |
|
|
Organisational Deviance
Core Idea: |
When illegal or unethical practices become embedded in an organisation’s culture |
Key Figures: |
Diane Vaughan (The Challenger Launch Decision) |
MKULTRA Relevance: |
Deviant practices institutionalised within CIA’s Technical Services Division. |
|
The culture rewarded secrecy, operational success, and innovation — not legality or ethics. |
Analytical Point: |
The deviance was not a rogue act, but part of CIA’s operational DNA. |
Routine Activity Theory
Core Idea: |
Crime occurs when motivated offenders, suitable targets, and lack of capable guardians converge |
Key Figures: |
Lawrence Cohen & Marcus Felson |
MKULTRA Relevance: |
Motivated Offenders: CIA operatives/scientists seeking Cold War advantage. |
|
Suitable Targets: Vulnerable human subjects. |
|
Absence of Guardians: Lack of oversight from Congress, courts, or public. |
Analytical Point: |
Secrecy acted as both a motivator and a shield against accountability. |
|