のに = Although |
Difference with: けれども (けど, けども, けれど) |
“Although X does Y, Z did/does…” Main clause is unexpected result that has already happened/ongoing/fact and the speaker has the feeling of surprise or disatsfaction |
“Although X does Y, Z did/does…” Main clause hasn’t happened yet and the possibility may happen or not. The speaker feels less personal about it. |
Wish, discontent, frustration or disappointment ⬅➡ When this is directed towards OTHERS |
Main Clause is yet to happen. Expresses the following: |
Main clause is an unexpected result and already happened/ongoing/fact. |
1. Request - てください / ないでください |
V-る + のに |
2. Command - しろ! / するな! |
い Adj + のに |
3. Ask for permission - てもいいですか |
な Adj / Noun + なのに |
4. Suggestion -レバいい / た方がいい |
|
5. Intention - しようとする / つもり / しようと思う |
|
6. Direct question - しますか |
|
7. Express a wish, discontent, frustration or disappointment about oneself. |
|
❗️❗️Note: As the main clause is yet to happen, there’s a possiblity that this may not happen like the listener may refuse the command, may not heed the suggestion or advise, speaker may not get permission, or change his mind about his intention because we don’t know that there’s a feeling of discontent and therefore, we cannot use のに。 |
Ex. 僕は毎日【運動】うんどうしているのに【痩せない】やせない。 Although I’m excercising everyday, I don’t lose weight. (Feeling of disappointment) |
"Although" |
彼は長い【間】あいだ日本語を勉強しているのにまだ日本語が上手に話せません。 Although he has studied Japanese for a long time, he still couldn’t speak Japanese well. |
Request: 暑いけれども、【窓】まどを開けないでください。 Although it is hot, please do not open the window. |
あのパソコンは安いのに誰も買わない。 Although that PC is cheap, no one buys it. (Statement of fact; conveys disappointment) |
Command: 彼が濃いと言っていたけれど、パーティーにくな。 Although he said to come, don't go to the party. |
彼は【貧乏】びんぼうなのに高い車を買いました。 Although he’s poor, he bought an expensive car. |
Permission: 【自信】じしんがないけどやってみてもいいですか。Although I don't have confidence, may I try to do it? |
Expressing displeasure: 雨が降っているのに、まだ出かけるんですか。Will you still go out despite the rain? |
Direct Straight Question: 雨が降っているけれど、まだ出かけますか。Although it's raining will you still go out? |